Soft Halyard or Line Shackle

[allene]

Originally Posted by Brion Toss

Hi,
Actually, in the shackle, the standing part of the eye is doubled, while in the new configuration it isn't. That makes the single standing part weaker than the doubled-but-stress-risen Diamond knot side.
Fair leads,
Brion

In the shackle think of two sides. One is just straight doubled amsteel and carries half the load. The other side has the eye and the diamond knot. Each side has half the load of the shackle. If the shackle has 150% of line strength, each side has 75%. His setup is exactly the same as the half with the eye and the knot, except that he has more knots.

Another way to look at is that in the shackle the strength should be 400% but it is 150% and breaks at the knot so the knot is 37% efficient strength wise. In his setup, the knot has two strands so it should be .37 x 200% = 75% and should break before the end with the eye in it.

There is something else interesting going on here.

Allen