[quote=benz;6082 ... climbing instructors want to teach the easiest possible bend and so lose the least amount of students later on.[/QUOTE]
This one, sadly, resonates as true. It's a patronizing, even contemptuous motivation, like teaching people pidgin English, because they aren't intelligent enough to handle real English. Those climbers, by and large, are not stupid; they just aren't familiar with knots. And even really simple knots can be -- and are, sometimes -- tied incorrectly. So climbing instructors are perpetuating inferior knots for everyone, for no good reason.
Rising nobly above this situation, I would stick to the question, of what is a good bend, and this can be answered with hard data. I'm a bit overextended on tests at the moment, but if anyone out there wants to pester someone into doing tests, you are looking for both strength and security. For the latter, note that many knots can be "dressed" in more than one way, most often in how the ends lay inside the knot. With the Strait Bend, for instance, they lie alongside each other, and either one might be "on top."
Fair leads,
Brion Toss
|